Well, you are staring at the research paper you have to analyze but have absolutely no idea of how to critique it. Do not panic! Just answer the questions presented below and you are sure to critique the research paper properly. The guiding questions given in this article can also be helpful in learning to critique your own research paper.

• How to critique a research paper: Question #1

Is a thesis statement stated clearly? Is it relevant to a research question?

• How to critique a research paper: Question # 2

Did the author present background information in the introduction?
A good introduction should help the reader understand what was investigated and why. Background information given in the introduction should also be relevant.

• How to critique research papers: Question # 3

Did the author state research methods clearly?
Are they applicable to the object of investigation? Did the author explain the effectiveness of the chosen research methods?

• How to critique a research paper: Question # 4

Did the author use reasonable ideas and explanations to support his/her thesis statement?
The main body of any research paper should be well grounded. To critique research papers from this perspective means to evaluate the supporting ideas the author used. Are they relevant enough?

• How to critique a research paper: Question # 5

Did the author compare comparable things?
Very often, writers use comparisons to explain their idea. What can you tell about the research paper you have to critique? Did the author choose quite comparable things to explain something?

• How to critique a research paper: Question # 6

Did the author explain figures and tables clearly?
All the tables, graphs, or diagrams should be labeled correctly, and results should be explained.

• How to critique research papers: Question # 7

Does data relate to the thesis statement or research question?

• How to critique a research paper: Question # 8

Did the author explain the results obtained?
Do results support or refute the research question or thesis statement of the paper?

• How to critique a research paper: Question # 9

Do you agree with the conclusions drawn?

What would you add to the conclusion? What would you say differently?
 
Consider the questions presented and learn to critique research papers appropriately.
 
You can also read about a research paper abstract and research paper bibliography on our website.